A recent federal court decision out of Michigan is a timely reminder that diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) goals—while lawful and laudable—can still generate legal risk if they appear to incentivize decisions based on race or gender. The court refused to dismiss a former employee’s reverse discrimination claims, finding that his allegations, if true, plausibly suggest unlawful bias. Continue reading
Employers striving to enhance diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) have faced stiff headwinds recently from the federal government. The EEOC’s latest release, “What You Should Know About DEI-Related Discrimination at Work,” is more about what employers can’t do than what they can to promote DEI.
Underscoring the importance of caution, the EEOC has reminded employers that race, sex, or ethnicity-based preferences in DEI programs risk violating anti-discrimination laws. These announcements specifically warn against quotas, explicit racial or gender preferences, and any programs that could create perceived or real discriminatory outcomes.
The guidance aims to “help employers take action to avoid unlawful DEI-related discrimination,” noted EEOC Acting Chair Andrea Lucas.
But are there lawful actions employers can take to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion principles?
Yes. Ms. Lucas herself provided eleven solutions last year on an episode of Cozen O’Connor’s Employment Law Now podcast, hosted by Michael Schmidt. You can listen to them starting at 31:33 in the recording. Additionally, I’ve summarized them below. Continue reading
And Kendrick Lamar and Drake may co-host a TED Talk on conflict resolution, the Dallas Cowboys may win the Super Bowl next year, and a job applicant may answer the “What’s your biggest weakness?” question honestly.
Let’s talk about why training on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) is unlikely to lead to a viable hostile work environment claim. Continue reading
For several weeks, employment law and HR professionals have been hearing about the term “illegal DEI.” But what did “illegal DEI” actually mean—especially to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), the federal discrimination watchdog? Until recently, that was anyone’s guess. Continue reading
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs have become a fixture in many modern workplaces, designed to promote a more inclusive environment. But recent federal scrutiny has raised new concerns for employers. A recent Executive Order directed the Chair of the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) to review large law firms for compliance with Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, igniting discussion over whether the EEOC is overstepping its authority in investigating DEI programs.
This post examines the differing perspectives on this issue: the reasons for Acting Chair Andrea Lucas’s increased scrutiny and the opposition raised by former EEOC officials who warn of procedural overreach. Continue reading
Despite two deciding judges expressing support for DEI, the Fourth Circuit unanimously ruled on Friday that two Executive Orders issued by President Trump, which seek to eliminate diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives from federal grant and contract processes, will remain in effect while legal challenges proceed. The Executive Orders claim that DEI programs promote race- and sex-based preferences that contradict American values of merit and hard work. Continue reading
About a year ago, a federal judge greenlit the lawsuit of a former university professor who alleged that his employer created a racially hostile work environment through various discussions and initiatives focused on antiracism and racial justice. Continue reading
Diversity, equity, and inclusion—better known as DEI—has been a hot topic lately. While DEI itself isn’t inherently illegal, critics have latched onto the idea of so-called “illegal DEI.” What exactly does that mean? Unclear. But a recent federal court case involving a law student who said she was discouraged from applying for a summer internship because of diversity-focused hiring criteria was giving me “illegal DEI” vibes.
The catch? Even if everything she claimed was true, the court never actually ruled on whether the hiring policy was legal or not. Here’s why.
The Lawsuit That Never Got Off the Ground
The federal government may be cracking down on what it deems “illegal DEI,” but a new memo from the Attorneys General of 15 states clarifies what most of us already knew: businesses can legally implement diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility initiatives. Moreover, these programs can help companies comply with civil rights laws and reduce the risk of discrimination claims. Here’s what employers need to know. Continue reading
A federal judge in Maryland has issued a nationwide injunction halting key provisions of two executive orders that sought to limit workplace diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs. The ruling means that, for now, employers—especially federal contractors and grant recipients—can continue their DEI efforts without immediate legal risk. Continue reading
The Employer Handbook Blog