When Can You Be Fired for Emailing Yourself Evidence of Discrimination?

PIP-paper-airplane-lands-in-mailbox-1024x576

You think you’re being discriminated against at work. The documents you’d use to prove it are in your work inbox. Do you hit Forward?


TL;DR: A data architect said she sent work documents to her personal email to preserve evidence of sex discrimination. The First Circuit upheld dismissal of her retaliation claim and left open whether copying the documents was protected.

📄 Read the First Circuit’s opinion


Two performance plans end up in a personal inbox

According to her complaint, a senior data architect had just been put on her second performance improvement plan (PIP). Her manager and HR gave her a choice. She could accept the PIP or resign with two months’ severance. She disputed the criticism and said she was being set up to fail.

She said she believed the company was discriminating against her, so she forwarded both PIPs, training certifications, and work emails to her personal account to preserve evidence. The company put her on leave after it discovered the transfers and fired her about a week after she sent the files, citing its security policy. The First Circuit upheld dismissal of her retaliation claim at the pleading stage.

When gathering your own evidence can be protected

The First Circuit assumed for purposes of the appeal that copying the documents was protected. Even with that assumption, the timing could only get the employee so far. Her complaint gave the court no basis to infer that the company knew she was gathering evidence for a discrimination claim. Her objection to the PIP could just as easily have sounded like a dispute about her performance.

So what if the company did know? In Verdrager v. Mintz, Massachusetts’ highest court said that copying company documents can qualify as protected activity under state law if the employee acted reasonably under the circumstances. The court starts by asking whether the employee could have obtained the documents in discovery. It then considers how the employee got them, how relevant they were, and whether copying them was reasonably necessary.

Think about what a rule against sending work files to a personal account can cover. Forwarding a PIP you were given and exporting a folder of coworkers’ personnel records could both trigger the same policy. The scope of the transfer, the sensitivity of the files, and their connection to a complaint can change the analysis.

What HR can do about work files in personal inboxes

A personal-email policy should spell out what employees can send

Say whether employees can forward work files to a personal account, when they need approval, and which tools they can use to work offsite or share files. Use an everyday example in training. If someone wants to finish a presentation at home, they should know how to do it without emailing a copy to Gmail.

Investigation comes before discipline

Have IT preserve the messages and attachments and limit further exposure. If there’s an underlying discrimination complaint, preserve those records too. Before deciding on discipline, check how the company handled comparable transfers and document what justifies any difference in treatment.

Employees need a way to get their own records

Give employees a clear way to request copies of their PIPs and reviews, including when they’re on leave or lose access to their work account. That’s one less reason for someone to forward a stack of emails just to keep a copy of the document HR handed them.

The next PIP someone forwards could end up as an exhibit twice. Once to show how the company treated them and again to explain why it fired them.

“Doing What’s Right – Not Just What’s Legal”
Contact Information