Sometimes the timing writes the headline for you. On October 31, a federal court in New Jersey decided a harassment case that involved an unforgettable Halloween costume and a reminder that bad taste is not always a legal violation.

---

TL;DR: An employee alleged sexual harassment after a doctor made crude comments about her body and showed coworkers a photo of himself in a Halloween “reaper” costume that, when the weapon moved, revealed a large penis prop. The court held the conduct was offensive but not severe or pervasive enough to create a hostile work environment under Title VII or the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination, and granted summary judgment to the employer.
🔗Read the full decision

---

From Creepy Comments to a Costume Gone Wrong

A medical employee reported that during one shift, a doctor repeatedly commented on her appearance, touched her hair, and while examining her knee told her it would “feel better with no clothes on.” She also reported that he had shown coworkers a picture of himself in a “reaper” Halloween costume that revealed a large penis prop when the weapon moved, and that he made similar remarks about other female staff.

Within two or three days of her complaint, HR met with her and opened an investigation. HR interviewed witnesses and the doctor, recommended termination, and a review panel issued a written warning instead under its internal review process. The employer adjusted schedules so the two would not work together. She did not work with him again after her complaint, and he resigned in December.

She was later assigned to another facility a few times for staffing needs, but never with the doctor. When one overlap appeared on the schedule, it was corrected.

Offensive? Yes. But Not “Severe or Pervasive.”

To win a hostile-environment case, an employee must show that the conduct was so severe or so pervasive that it changed the terms and conditions of employment. Courts look at how frequent and serious the conduct was, whether it involved threats or touching, and whether it disrupted work.

Here, the behavior was confined mostly to one day, followed months later by the Halloween-costume photo. The court found that the photo, while lewd, was neither physically threatening nor part of an ongoing pattern. It was inappropriate, not unlawful.

HR Saved the Day (and the Case)

The employer avoided liability because HR did nearly everything right. It acted within days, interviewed everyone involved, documented each step, and kept the two employees apart. The written warning might not have been as harsh as the complainant hoped, but it was enough to stop the behavior.

Courts do not second-guess reasonable corrective action that actually works. Once the conduct stopped and there were no repeat incidents, the employer’s prompt response became its best defense.

This is exactly why employers need clear reporting procedures and trained HR teams. The speed and thoroughness of an investigation can mean the difference between an awkward HR file and a lawsuit that sticks.

Three Takeaways Before the Next Costume Party

1. Move quickly and document everything. Early interviews, written findings, and schedule changes show the company took the complaint seriously.
2. Separate the parties when possible. Physical separation is simple, effective, and persuasive evidence of a reasonable response.
3. Set costume rules in advance. If your workplace allows costumes, ban sexual or suggestive themes and any props that could be perceived as sexual.

A Final Word on Costumes

If your company celebrates Halloween, remember that “creative” does not mean “career-ending.” Here are a few costumes that should never make it past the lobby:

• Sexy HR Compliance Officer – The irony will be lost on no one.
• Inflatable Anatomically Correct Anything – If it needs an air pump, it does not belong in the office.
• ICE Agent – HR doesn’t have a form for that level of poor judgment.
• P. Diddy – If your costume idea requires a risk assessment and a PR strategy, skip it.
• The Missing Epstein Files – Probably not the kind of “case file” HR wants opened at the office party.

 

After all, HR has a sense of humor, just not about lawsuits.