Can you eliminate discrimination claims by hiring minority replacements?

Villainc.svgYeah, no.

When a person claims that he wasn’t promoted because of his race, or terminated because of her gender, or brings some other claim of disparate treatment, that person must demonstrate several elements:

For example, in a failure-to-promote case, at a minimum, the plaintiff must establish four things:

  1. (s)he belongs to a protected group under Title VII;
  2. (s)he was qualified for the promotion;
  3. (s)he was not promoted; and
  4. the employer promoted someone else

In a recent federal court opinion, as a defense to a failure-to-promote claim, the employer argued that the fourth element requires a minority plaintiff to demonstrate that the company promoted a non-minority employee instead.

That argument has some superficial appeal. For example, consider a termination situation in which a company fired a woman and replaced her with a woman. That would suggest that gender was a not a motivating factor in the employment decision. But, then again, it’s not dispositive. Here’s what an Oklahoma federal court had to say about that:

It would preclude suits by employers who hire and fire minority employees in an attempt to prevent them from vesting in employment benefits or developing a track record to qualify for promotion. It would also preclude a suit against an employer who terminates a woman it negatively perceives as a “feminist” and replaces her with a woman who is willing to be subordinate to her male co-workers or replaces an African-American with an African-American who is perceived to “know his place.” Although each of these situations involves wrongfully-motived terminations, under the rule advocated by the Defendants, the terminated employee would be unable to meet the prima facie burden. Such a result is unacceptable.

Obviously, the easy solution here is don’t let a protected-class characteristic motivate an employment decision. But, at the other end of the spectrum, biased managers who replace a minority employee with a minority employee should avoid twisting their handlebar mustaches prematurely.

There may be a viable discrimination claim after all.

Image Credit: “Villainc” by J.J. at the English language Wikipedia. Licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0 via Commons.
Updated: